In the aftermath of the school shootings in Parkland, Florida, the defender of gun manufacturers (i.e., the NRA and the Republican Party) have made their usual remarks about now not being the time to discuss gun laws (even Secretary of State Rex Tillerson parroted this line during a press conference in Lebanon). And, they have brought up the increasingly discussed issue that persons with mental health issues should not have access to guns. For the NRA and Republicans, the reference to mental health issues is a way for them to deflect any discussion about gun laws directly. They typically discuss how everyone should inform the authorities when they see social media or other signs of mental instability or a propensity toward gun violence. That's certainly a good idea, but that doesn't stop a person with mental issues from getting a gun. And, it does not touch how to deal with a person whose mental illness has developed after he has legally purchased a gun. But, since the Republicans and the NRA are using mental illness as their main talking point now, those who actually want to do something about limiting such persons from possessing guns should take the issue and run with it. That is, federal legislation should be proposed that required mental illness evaluations for anyone seeking to purchase a gun, ammunition or accessories (in any venue, whether privately, at a gun show or in a store), the gun should then be registered and a mental illness re-evaluation should be required every 5 years in order to allow that person to continue to own and possess such items. Of course, a process and a system would be required to implement these rules (authorized psychiatrists would need to be qualified, the mental illness evaluation would need to be incorporated into the background check system, etc.). Of course, mental illness checks would delay the purchase of a gun, but almost no one needs to purchase a gun immediately - to say otherwise is disingenuous and really just an attempt to limit regulation. The NRA and the Republicans will come up with all kinds of arguments of why such mental illness evaluations would be a violation of the 2nd Amendment, etc., but if supporters of decreased gun violence are looking for an opening for some Republicans and their supporters find a justification for how they can help reduce gun violence, legislation proposing mental illness evaluations made be an opportunity.
16 February 2018
15 February 2018
Now Is The Time
Another mass shooting at another school in the U.S. I expect the same round of actions and discussions: A pile of flowers and candles will start to appear at the school; local leaders and parents (especially parents who lost their children) will speak; most will speak about the children that they loved; some will speak out against the lack of gun laws or the lack of enforcement of the gun laws; a few politicians will get press coverage for proposing some change (even a little change) to our laws relating to access to certain types of guns, background checks, etc; others, including the National Rifle Association, will say it is disrespectful and too soon to talk about changes to the law and enforcement while people are mourning; a bill will eventually appear in Congress; that bill will sit and then die; another shooting will happen and the cycle will start again.
Although candle-lit vigils, piles of flowers and speeches may express grief and get a lot of coverage, that's exactly what the NRA wants to happen. They don't want protests, discussion in legislatures, etc. because they know over time that they can manage the situation to make changes go away. To the contrary, they can exploit the situation to put more fear into the NRA followers that stronger gun laws may come into being, get those followers to give more money to the NRA and then the NRA and their followers will put more pressure on the legislatures to defend the status quo. They have even become good at exploiting such events by arguing that every teacher should carry a gun and that students should be able to carry guns.
A few things could happen to change this cycle. First, someone or some credible organization could start to explain to the followers of the NRA that the NRA is lying to them; the NRA does not care about them and the 2nd Amendment, except to the extent that those followers empower the NRA act on behalf of the gun industry (not gun owners) to sell more guns. That is, the followers of the NRA are being lied to and being duped by the NRA, not being supported by the NRA. Second, call out legislators and others who call these events "tragedies" or, as Florida Governor Rick Scott said yesterday, that the shooter was "pure evil". This type of language is intentionally describing these events in unknowable, unstoppable and even religious tones. But, these events are not tragedies, they are direct results of ignorance, politics and culture that lead to these outcomes. The shooter is not "evil", he is almost always mentally ill and yet has had access to powerful weapons. Finally, and I think this is the most important thing that can be done, do not conduct vigils and speeches of rememberance. Instead, do protests and don't stop until changes are made. Imagine the press coverage and the pressure on legislatures if all the surviving children at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School refused to go back to school until actual changes were made; if they had sit-ins, speeches and protests on the school grounds for as long as it takes; if the parents and children in those protests refused to allow NRA apologists like Governor Scott and Senator Marco Rubio from participating or attending and to shout back whenever they or others make the well-tested excuses for the NRA and the lack of action.
One thing is clear, as it should be clear immediately after every other such event, Now Is The Time! Now Is The Time to stop accepting the NRA's lies. Now Is The Time to reject the fatalist language of our legislatures that these events are unstoppable. Now Is The Time to stop playing into the hands of the NRA by having vigils and speeches. Now Is The Time to have massive and long-standing protests after each event. Students, parents and teachers at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, Now Is The Time to change the entire direction of these issues. Go on strike. Student and teachers should not go back in the school, but go to the school and yell like hell until you are heard and changes are made. Now Is The Time.
03 February 2018
Back Blogging
To the 1 or 2 people who may be watching this space, my good friend Jorge Costales pointed out to me that I have not posted in over a year. That's partly because this last year was a complicated year with lots of transitions. But, that's all in place now. Hopefully, I can live up to Jorge's standards going forward.
20 December 2016
Fake Titles
I recently have had an energetic LinkedIn exchange with someone prancing around New York City claiming that he is "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia". He voluntarily calls himself that on LinkedIn, a public social media site. He posted a photo of himself receiving some award from some other "HRH" of Yugoslavia and was quite proud of it. I had the audacity to comment on his post to say that he should stop using such a title, if for no other reason than because Yugoslavia no longer exists. And, it is now divided up into various republics which are republics and have no royal families or systems. He aggressively replied to my comment by claiming that I was an "ignorant American" and didn't know anything about history. He then professed that "I have ancestors" who were royal family members and, apparently, he thinks that entitles him to continue using a silly title like "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia". He also said that I needed to better understand "constitutional law". So, when I asked him to explain exactly why he is entitled to call himself a "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia" and to which constitution he was referring, he continued to throw insults at me, but made no actual arguments for why he should be calling himself by some non-existent title. Then, he blocked me from his LinkedIn account. That all was not very convincing.
Next, his cousin (apparently half New Yorker and half "royal family of Yugoslavia") jumps into the discussion. She argues that I have no business commenting on her cousin's title and that it is a shame that I am so "ignorant" (apparently a favorite word of "royal Yugoslavs"). And, she tried to make a comparison that calling her cousin "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia" was akin to calling Bill Clinton "Mr. Clinton" instead of "President Client. I told her that there can be no comparison between the titles of democratically elected officials and so-called inherited and unelected titles, especially of a non-existing royal family and royal system. I also clarified that Bill Clinton is no longer President and so, of course, he is now Mr. Clinton, although ex US officials often love to call themselves by their former positions (e.g., President Clinton, Secretary Clinton, Speaker Gingrich). When they do that, it is "trafficking in titles" in the same way that "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia" (and countless Prince and Princesses of Nowhere) like to do. Of course, having no valid argument, she also again called me "ignorant" and blocked me from her LinkedIn account. This is apparently a favored social media tactic of the "royal family of Yugoslavia".
It is all pretty clear to me. Any so-called royal system was the result of someone many centuries ago conquering some land, subjugating its people, giving himself and his descendants a bunch of silly titles and declaring that they were the representatives of God on Earth (at least for the area that they controlled). The fact that someone is a descendent of such a made-up system, especially one that no longer exists, doesn't mean that any of us need to (or should) call them by the silly titles that they have given to themselves. More to the point, we should oppose that nonsense wherever we find it.
Next, his cousin (apparently half New Yorker and half "royal family of Yugoslavia") jumps into the discussion. She argues that I have no business commenting on her cousin's title and that it is a shame that I am so "ignorant" (apparently a favorite word of "royal Yugoslavs"). And, she tried to make a comparison that calling her cousin "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia" was akin to calling Bill Clinton "Mr. Clinton" instead of "President Client. I told her that there can be no comparison between the titles of democratically elected officials and so-called inherited and unelected titles, especially of a non-existing royal family and royal system. I also clarified that Bill Clinton is no longer President and so, of course, he is now Mr. Clinton, although ex US officials often love to call themselves by their former positions (e.g., President Clinton, Secretary Clinton, Speaker Gingrich). When they do that, it is "trafficking in titles" in the same way that "HRH Prince of Yugoslavia" (and countless Prince and Princesses of Nowhere) like to do. Of course, having no valid argument, she also again called me "ignorant" and blocked me from her LinkedIn account. This is apparently a favored social media tactic of the "royal family of Yugoslavia".
It is all pretty clear to me. Any so-called royal system was the result of someone many centuries ago conquering some land, subjugating its people, giving himself and his descendants a bunch of silly titles and declaring that they were the representatives of God on Earth (at least for the area that they controlled). The fact that someone is a descendent of such a made-up system, especially one that no longer exists, doesn't mean that any of us need to (or should) call them by the silly titles that they have given to themselves. More to the point, we should oppose that nonsense wherever we find it.
13 December 2016
Trump, Russia and China
President-Elect Donald Trump has everyone guessing what his foreign policy will be like, especially in relation to Russia and China. There is wide-spread concern that a President Trump will be too friendly to Russia. I find that to be a bit strange in that he has never actually said he liked Russia or Putin or that they are anything other than unfriendly foreign powers. Yes, he may admire Putin's strength or various successes, but there is no evidence that he desires the outcomes of Putin's various activities. In any event, my calculation is that this "play nice with Russia" approach is one of the biggest head fakes in history. My view is based on a number of realities and then a possible strategy.
The first reality is that China is a way more important competition to the United States than Russia is. Russia has a horrible economy, ineffective or non-existent social and other institutions and little prospect for economic growth or global influence outside of its traditional sphere of influence. Yes, Russia has a capable military to interfere in those areas of traditional influence, but it scarcely has the financial capability to do that, let alone to go beyond those areas. And, Russia's kleptocratic economy does not bode well for improving Russia's situation, even if Western sanctions are eventually lifted. China, on the other hand, is a massive economic power with much more room to grow, albeit at a slower growth rate than over the last few decades. Despite lots of potential pitfalls in China's future (very high levels of debt, inefficiently allocated capital, etc.), there is every reason to believe that China's GDP and GDP per capita will continue to grow. And, consequently, China will be very capable of financing growing political, economic, military and social influences around the world. Russia and China have no comparison. The main issue would be that the US would not want to run a fight against both of them at the same time.
As such, my view is that Trump's approach of playing nice with Putin is that Putin and Russia cannot really hurt the U.S. (perhaps other than via cyberspace, which is another thing and I doubt we'll play nice on that front) and so it makes sense to at least pretend to work with Russia for now while the US takes on China on all sorts of issues and levels - South China Sea, North Korea, Chinese cyber attacks, trade, currency, Taiwan and Hong Kong, etc. The main point is to not be nice to Russia, but to not encourage Russia and China to team up as an anti-US front. Thus, softening relations with Russia can be explained as preparing for the direct attack on China issues, not anything to do with liking Russia or Putin.
The first reality is that China is a way more important competition to the United States than Russia is. Russia has a horrible economy, ineffective or non-existent social and other institutions and little prospect for economic growth or global influence outside of its traditional sphere of influence. Yes, Russia has a capable military to interfere in those areas of traditional influence, but it scarcely has the financial capability to do that, let alone to go beyond those areas. And, Russia's kleptocratic economy does not bode well for improving Russia's situation, even if Western sanctions are eventually lifted. China, on the other hand, is a massive economic power with much more room to grow, albeit at a slower growth rate than over the last few decades. Despite lots of potential pitfalls in China's future (very high levels of debt, inefficiently allocated capital, etc.), there is every reason to believe that China's GDP and GDP per capita will continue to grow. And, consequently, China will be very capable of financing growing political, economic, military and social influences around the world. Russia and China have no comparison. The main issue would be that the US would not want to run a fight against both of them at the same time.
As such, my view is that Trump's approach of playing nice with Putin is that Putin and Russia cannot really hurt the U.S. (perhaps other than via cyberspace, which is another thing and I doubt we'll play nice on that front) and so it makes sense to at least pretend to work with Russia for now while the US takes on China on all sorts of issues and levels - South China Sea, North Korea, Chinese cyber attacks, trade, currency, Taiwan and Hong Kong, etc. The main point is to not be nice to Russia, but to not encourage Russia and China to team up as an anti-US front. Thus, softening relations with Russia can be explained as preparing for the direct attack on China issues, not anything to do with liking Russia or Putin.
23 November 2016
FaceBook and China
According to New York Times story today, Facebook is developing a tool to effectively allow China to block content on its news feed. In return, Facebook would finally get to enter the Chinese market. Although Facebook does provide blocking of certain content in other countries (e.g., content that is allegedly inconsistent with local culture and laws in places like Pakistan), the apparent willingness to cooperate with China's government to block actual news that helps it blockade information to the Chinese people is a step way beyond what Facebook has done to date. And, it further reflects that Mark Zuckerberg's consistent statements about facilitating communications for the common good is a lie; he and Facebook clearly are only interested in becoming more profitable, even if that means cooperating with the massive censorship programs of the Chinese government. And, while I'm generally in favor of companies making as much money as possible based on the quality of its services and products in the market, directly cooperating with an oppressive government and developing tools to facilitate that oppression should called what it is: collaboration in censorship and oppression. The US government should be concerned that US companies are actively supporting and encouraging the oppression of millions of people by a foreign government, especially one that is hostile to the US. Perhaps the US government should also consider passing laws that prohibit US companies (and Facebook is not the only one; also, Cisco and others) from doing business with or in such countries if their business is used to facilitate such oppression.
19 November 2016
"Doing Evil All The Time" Is A More Appropriate Motto
You may recall that Google's initial motto was said to be "Do No Evil" or "Don't Be Evil". According to the Wikipedia site about this, it was proposed by one or another employee in 2000 and has generally been considered part of Google's Code of Conduct. That sounds great. And, other large technology companies that arise out of Silicon Valley tend to make public statements that they are saving the world in one way or the other by increasing global communications, etc. In some circumstances, the various technologies have, indeed, been crucial towards advancing certain good causes. For example, the Arab Spring events resulted in several stories of how Twitter essentially facilitated a revolution against dictators. And, depending on your view of the "main stream media", Donald Trump's use of Twitter was an extremely cost-effective way to get his views into the political consciousness and supported his successful election bid.
I'm sure there are many, many examples of all the good things that Google, Twitter, Snap Chat, etc. have been used for (sometimes even better than sharing funny cat videos). However, these companies have also been complicit with China in preventing important data from reaching the Chinese people. More important, what most of these companies have in common is that they capture and devour and then sell your data. That's really all they do. Google does it under the guise of providing free search information. Snap Chat and Facebook do it under the guise that they are helping people share information with each other. Twitter does it under the guise that they are helping people communicate.
They don't charge membership fees to the users. As such, the business models of all of these companies are driven by one thing and only one thing: acquiring the public's personal data and selling it to advertisers or other consumers of the data that want to sell things and services to the users. The sophisticated algorithms and other tools used to acquire, analyze, slice and dice and sell the data to third parties result in "targeted advertising" that has developed into virtual mind control over their user populations (which means nearly everyone). It results in a all sorts of companies using the massive amounts of data to push consumerism like never before. For example, I was once looking for a faucet when I was re-doing my kitchen. When I left the kitchen renovation websites, I was followed around on other sites for days by "targeted advertising" of the same faucets that I had looked at. I also once heard a Google executive state that gathering all of this information was really good for everyone by explaining that it would be great if when our sneakers were wearing down and we were walking by a sports store then the sports store would know you were close by and would send an advertisement to your phone to sell you those sneakers that you so desperately needed at that moment. From my perspective, that would effectively a form of mind control; a process by which "free will" is taken away from us but we don't know it. Even if that sneaker example sounded useful at some level, there is no way the sneaker company is going to wait to push those sneakers on you only when your sneaker is likely to be worn out. Instead, they'd be constantly trying to get you to buy then earlier than that and to buy multiple styles and colors.
This omnipresent and rapacious data collection and usage is the only real reason these companies exist. Their business models are far from living up to the naïve idea that they "Do No Evil". Instead, the manner in which they are knowing and using virtually everything bit of information about our lives is what I would call "Doing Evil All The Time".
Very recently, some of these tech companies have lost data-usage regulatory law suits in the UK and the EU. These cases must be very worrisome to the big-data tech companies that are virtually trying to know and track every bit of information about you. Personally, I think the government should very aggressively limit and regulate these companies' acquisition and usage of the our data. I would even go so far as to say that the license and usage agreements should be strictly limited by new laws that restrict the data-collection and data-usage provisions the license agreements that we click without reading all the time. Sure, there may be fewer world-saving technology companies, but at least our world will be less controlled by these companies and the amount of wasteful consumerism would decrease.
I'm sure there are many, many examples of all the good things that Google, Twitter, Snap Chat, etc. have been used for (sometimes even better than sharing funny cat videos). However, these companies have also been complicit with China in preventing important data from reaching the Chinese people. More important, what most of these companies have in common is that they capture and devour and then sell your data. That's really all they do. Google does it under the guise of providing free search information. Snap Chat and Facebook do it under the guise that they are helping people share information with each other. Twitter does it under the guise that they are helping people communicate.
They don't charge membership fees to the users. As such, the business models of all of these companies are driven by one thing and only one thing: acquiring the public's personal data and selling it to advertisers or other consumers of the data that want to sell things and services to the users. The sophisticated algorithms and other tools used to acquire, analyze, slice and dice and sell the data to third parties result in "targeted advertising" that has developed into virtual mind control over their user populations (which means nearly everyone). It results in a all sorts of companies using the massive amounts of data to push consumerism like never before. For example, I was once looking for a faucet when I was re-doing my kitchen. When I left the kitchen renovation websites, I was followed around on other sites for days by "targeted advertising" of the same faucets that I had looked at. I also once heard a Google executive state that gathering all of this information was really good for everyone by explaining that it would be great if when our sneakers were wearing down and we were walking by a sports store then the sports store would know you were close by and would send an advertisement to your phone to sell you those sneakers that you so desperately needed at that moment. From my perspective, that would effectively a form of mind control; a process by which "free will" is taken away from us but we don't know it. Even if that sneaker example sounded useful at some level, there is no way the sneaker company is going to wait to push those sneakers on you only when your sneaker is likely to be worn out. Instead, they'd be constantly trying to get you to buy then earlier than that and to buy multiple styles and colors.
This omnipresent and rapacious data collection and usage is the only real reason these companies exist. Their business models are far from living up to the naïve idea that they "Do No Evil". Instead, the manner in which they are knowing and using virtually everything bit of information about our lives is what I would call "Doing Evil All The Time".
Very recently, some of these tech companies have lost data-usage regulatory law suits in the UK and the EU. These cases must be very worrisome to the big-data tech companies that are virtually trying to know and track every bit of information about you. Personally, I think the government should very aggressively limit and regulate these companies' acquisition and usage of the our data. I would even go so far as to say that the license and usage agreements should be strictly limited by new laws that restrict the data-collection and data-usage provisions the license agreements that we click without reading all the time. Sure, there may be fewer world-saving technology companies, but at least our world will be less controlled by these companies and the amount of wasteful consumerism would decrease.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)